Here’s what HIVE AI had to say about “What’s the difference between an employee and independent contractor?”:
The distinction between an employee and an independent contractor is one of the most fundamental and complex issues in tax law, with significant implications for both the worker and the entity paying for services. This classification affects tax withholding obligations, employment tax responsibilities, benefit eligibility, and various deduction opportunities.
The Core Legal Test
The general rule is that an individual is an independent contractor if you, the person for whom the services are performed, have the right to control or direct only the result of the work and not the means and methods of accomplishing the result. IRS – Publication 15-A: Employer’s Supplemental Tax Guide (Supplement to Pub. 15, Employer’s Tax Guide) Conversely, under common-law rules, anyone who performs services for you is generally your employee if you have the right to control what will be done and how it will be done. What matters is that you have the right to control the details of how the services are performed. IRS – Publication 15-A: Employer’s Supplemental Tax Guide (Supplement to Pub. 15, Employer’s Tax Guide) IRS – Publication 15-A: Employer’s Supplemental Tax Guide (Supplement to Pub. 15, Employer’s Tax Guide)
The determination is not based on job titles or contractual designations alone. How a firm classifies a worker is not a choice: For federal employment tax purposes, federal law determines whether a worker is an employee, independent contractor, or another category. IRS IRM 4.23.5 Technical Guidelines for Employment Tax Issues Employment status cannot be determined simply by looking at job titles. Facts must be developed to make a correct determination. IRS IRM 4.23.5 Technical Guidelines for Employment Tax Issues
Three Categories of Evidence
The IRS uses three main categories of evidence to determine worker classification, each examining different aspects of the working relationship:
Behavioral Control
This category examines whether the business has the right to direct and control how the worker performs the task. Key factors include the type and degree of instructions given to the worker, the extent of training provided, and whether the business sets work schedules or requires specific methods to complete the work.
Financial Control
Facts that show whether the business has a right to control the business aspects of the worker’s job include the following. The extent to which the worker has unreimbursed business expenses. Independent contractors are more likely to have unreimbursed expenses than are employees. IRS – Publication 15-A: Employer’s Supplemental Tax Guide (Supplement to Pub. 15, Employer’s Tax Guide) An independent contractor often has a significant investment in the facilities or tools they use in performing services for someone else. IRS – Publication 15-A: Employer’s Supplemental Tax Guide (Supplement to Pub. 15, Employer’s Tax Guide) Additionally, an independent contractor is generally free to seek out business opportunities. Independent contractors often advertise, maintain a visible business location, and are available to work in the relevant market. IRS – Publication 15-A: Employer’s Supplemental Tax Guide (Supplement to Pub. 15, Employer’s Tax Guide)
The method of payment also matters significantly. An employee is generally guaranteed a regular wage amount for an hourly, weekly, or other period of time. IRS – Publication 15-A: Employer’s Supplemental Tax Guide (Supplement to Pub. 15, Employer’s Tax Guide) Independent contractors, by contrast, are typically paid per project or based on results achieved.
Relationship of the Parties
Factors which illustrate how the parties perceive their relationship include the intent of the parties, as expressed in written contracts; the provision of, or lack of employee benefits; the right of the parties to terminate the relationship; the permanency of the relationship; and whether the services performed are part of the service recipient’s regular business activities. IRS IRM 4.23.10 Report Writing Guide for Employment Tax Examinations
The permanency factor is particularly important. If a business engages a worker with the expectation that the relationship will continue indefinitely, rather than for a specific project or period, this is generally considered evidence of the intent to create an employment relationship. IRS IRM 4.23.10 Report Writing Guide for Employment Tax Examinations
Tax Implications and Responsibilities
The classification has profound tax consequences for both parties:
For Employees
Your employer must withhold income tax and your portion of social security and Medicare taxes. Also, your employer is responsible for paying social security, Medicare, and unemployment (FUTA) taxes on your wages. IRS – Publication 1779: Independent Contractor or Employee Your employer must give you a Form W-2, Wage and Tax Statement, showing the amount of taxes withheld from your pay. IRS – Publication 1779: Independent Contractor or Employee
For Independent Contractors
The business may be required to give you Form 1099-MISC, Miscellaneous Income, to report what it has paid to you. IRS – Publication 1779: Independent Contractor or Employee You are responsible for paying your own income tax and self-employment tax (Self-Employment Contributions Act – SECA). The business does not withhold taxes from your pay. IRS – Publication 1779: Independent Contractor or Employee You may need to make estimated tax payments during the year to cover your tax liabilities. IRS – Publication 1779: Independent Contractor or Employee
Court-Applied Factors
Courts have developed a comprehensive framework for analyzing these relationships. Relevant factors in determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor include: (1) the degree of control exercised by the principal over the details of the work; (2) which party invests in the facilities used by the worker; (3) the opportunity of the worker for profit or loss; (4) whether the principal can discharge the individual; (5) whether the work is part of the principal’s regular business; (6) the permanency of the relationship; and (7) the relationship the parties believe they were creating. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Atlantic Coast Masonry, Inc.
The investment factor is particularly telling. The fact that a worker has no investment in the facilities used in the work is indicative of an employer-employee relationship. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Bradley M. McGuigan & Shirley W. McGuigan Conversely, the fact that a worker provides his or her own tools or owns a vehicle that is used for his work weighs toward finding him to be an independent contractor. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Jorge Quintanilla
The profit and loss opportunity is another crucial distinguishing factor. An opportunity for profit or the risk of loss on the basis of the worker’s own efforts and skill indicates independent contractor status. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Bradley M. McGuigan & Shirley W. McGuigan An opportunity to earn a profit or suffer a loss also distinguishes an independent contractor from an employee. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Jorge Quintanilla
Professional Services Exception
Certain professionals are generally presumed to be independent contractors. People such as doctors, veterinarians, and auctioneers who work in an independent trade, business, or profession in which they offer their services to the public are generally not employees. However, whether such people are employees or independent contractors depends on the facts in each case. IRS – Publication 15-A: Employer’s Supplemental Tax Guide (Supplement to Pub. 15, Employer’s Tax Guide) Individuals such as physicians, lawyers, dentists, veterinarians, construction contractors, public stenographers, and auctioneers, engaged in the pursuit of an independent trade, business, or profession, in which they offer their services to the public, are independent contractors and not employees. Tresuary Reg. Treasury Regulation 31.3121(d)-1
Practical Considerations
The distinction is not always clear-cut, and the line between an employee and an independent contractor is not always easy to draw. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Reflectxion Resources, Inc. In making a determination, look at the entire relationship between a taxpayer and a worker. The relationship often has several facets, some indicating the taxpayer has control, while others indicate it does not. IRS IRM 4.23.5 Technical Guidelines for Employment Tax Issues
Misclassification can have serious consequences. If an employer has incorrectly characterized an employee as an independent contractor, then correcting the error may require after-the-fact payment of the employment taxes, possibly with penalties, additions to tax, and interest. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Reflectxion Resources, Inc.
The determination ultimately requires a careful analysis of all relevant facts and circumstances, with no single factor being determinative. The key is understanding that the fundamental test revolves around the right to control not just what work is done, but how it is accomplished, along with the economic realities of the relationship between the parties.
Sources
- IRS – Publication 15-A: Employer’s Supplemental Tax Guide (Supplement to Pub. 15, Employer’s Tax Guide)
- IRS – Publication 1779: Independent Contractor or Employee
- IRS IRM 4.23.5 Technical Guidelines for Employment Tax Issues
- IRS IRM 4.23.10 Report Writing Guide for Employment Tax Examinations
- Treasury Regulation 31.3121(d)-1
Try Your AI Tax Assistant for Free!
Ready to transform your practice with agentic AI in tax? See firsthand how our cutting-edge AI tax tools can revolutionize your approach to tax research and planning.