Here’s what HIVE AI had to say about “Is advance payment or deposits taxable in the year received?”:
Taxability of Advance Payments and Deposits
When determining whether advance payments or deposits are taxable in the year received, it’s important to understand the distinction between the two and the applicable tax rules for each.
Advance Payments
Generally, you report an advance payment for goods, services, or other items as income in the year you receive the payment. IRS – Publication 525: Taxable and Nontaxable Income This is the default rule for most taxpayers.
Advance payments for goods or services are generally taxable in the year of receipt. This principle has been established by several Supreme Court cases including Schlude v. Commissioner, American Automobile Association v. United States, and Automobile Club of Michigan v. Commissioner. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Gateway Hotel Partners, LLC, Gateway Interest Acquisition Corp., Tax Matters Partner
The right to receive income generally occurs when (1) the payment is earned through performance, (2) payment is due to the taxpayer, or (3) payment is received by the taxpayer, whichever happens earliest. Therefore, an advance payment of income generally is includible in gross income in the taxable year received. TAM-142802-05
Because advances are taxable for the year in which they are paid, any advance would be taxable for the year it was received. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: George Lawrence Starke
Deferral Method for Advance Payments
However, if you use an accrual method of accounting and are otherwise eligible, you can elect to postpone including the advance payment in income until the next year. More information about this can be found in IRS Publication 538. IRS – Publication 525: Taxable and Nontaxable Income
Generally, you include an advance payment in income in the year in which you receive it. However, you may use the deferral method for qualifying advance payments. IRS – Publication 538: Accounting Periods and Methods
An advance payment for which the taxpayer uses the Deferral Method provided in section 5.02 of Rev. Proc. 2004-34 is includible in computing taxable income for an annualization period in accordance with that method of accounting, except that any amount not included in computing taxable income by the end of the taxable year succeeding the taxable year of receipt is includible in computing taxable income on the last day of such succeeding taxable year. Tresuary Reg. 1.6655-2
Under Revenue Procedure 2004-34, a taxpayer who receives an advance payment includes the advance payment in taxable income in the year of receipt to the extent that the payment is earned (if the taxpayer does not have an AFS) or, if the taxpayer has an AFS, to the extent that the payment is included in revenues in the AFS. The taxpayer includes the remaining amount of the advance payment in taxable income in the next taxable year, unless the next taxable year is a short year of 92 days or less. T.D. 9941
Under the Deferral Method, a taxpayer must include the advance payment in gross income for the taxable year of receipt to the extent recognized in revenues in its applicable financial statement for that taxable year, and include the remaining amount of the advance payment in gross income in the next succeeding taxable year. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Aimee A. & Ryan A. Cvancara
If the taxpayer does not have an applicable financial statement, a taxpayer using the Deferral Method must include the advance payment in gross income for the taxable year of receipt to the extent earned in that taxable year and include the remaining amount of the advance payment in gross income in the next succeeding taxable year. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Aimee A. & Ryan A. Cvancara
For advance payments, the tax code allows taxpayers to (i) include any portion of such advance payment that is required to be included in gross income in the taxable year in which such payment is received, and (ii) include the remaining portion of such advance payment in gross income in the taxable year following the taxable year in which such payment is received. IRC § 451(c)
Specific Types of Advance Payments
Revenue Procedure 2004-34 applies to numerous types of advance payments beyond advance payments for the provision of services and sales of goods. For example, it applies to advance payments for the use of intellectual property and software, the occupancy or use of property if the occupancy or use is ancillary to the provision of services, guaranty or warranty contracts, subscriptions, memberships in organizations, and eligible gift card sales. T.D. 9941
Certain types of prepayments are excluded from the definition of advance payments and are ineligible for this deferral method such as some types of rent or insurance premiums. See section 451(c)(B) for exclusions to the term “advance payment.” IRS – Publication 538: Accounting Periods and Methods
In the context of timber sales, where certain conditions are met, amounts received or accrued prior to cutting (such as advance royalty payments or minimum royalty payments) shall be treated under section 631(b) as realized from the sale of timber if the contract of disposal provides that such amounts are to be applied as payment for timber subsequently cut. Tresuary Reg. 1.631-2
Deposits vs. Advance Payments
Unlike advance payments, a deposit is not includible in gross income when received. In Commissioner v. Indianapolis Power & Light Co., the Supreme Court considered whether deposits received by an electric utility company (IPL) should be treated as taxable advance payments or nontaxable deposits. IPL required customers with suspect credit to make deposits to insure prompt payment of future utility bills. The customer was entitled to a refund of the deposit after making timely payments for several months or satisfying a credit test. The customer could choose to take the refund by cash or check or to apply the refund against future bills. TAM-142802-05
An advance payment is treated as a payment of tax and will be refunded to you only if you make a claim for refund and IRS determines you are entitled to a refund. Another difference between deposits and advance payments is that a higher interest rate will usually be paid on refunds of advance payments than on returned deposits. IRS – Notice 1016: How to Stop Interest on Your Account
A loan is not taxable income when received because the taxpayer has an obligation to repay it. By comparison, an advance for future services is taxable in the year it is received. Whether an advance is a bona fide loan is a question of fact that turns on whether the borrower and lender intended to make and enforce monetary repayment at the time the advance was made. Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Lundy Nath & Tanya Nath
It is well settled that the mere receipt of possession of money does not by itself constitute taxable income. “We accept as sound law the rule that a taxpayer need not treat as income moneys which he did not receive under a claim of right, which were not his to keep, and which he was required to transmit to someone else as a mere conduit.” Dawson U.S. Tax Court Opinions: Faysal Warfa & Aisha Ibrahim This principle applies to deposits held as an intermediary.
Distinguishing Between Deposits and Advance Payments
The key factor in determining whether a payment is a taxable advance payment or a nontaxable deposit is whether the recipient has complete dominion and control over the funds. If the recipient has unrestricted use of the funds and is not obligated to return them, the payment is likely an advance payment that is taxable when received. If the recipient must return the funds under certain conditions and does not have unrestricted use of the funds, the payment is likely a deposit that is not taxable when received.
Special Considerations for Certain Advance Payments
Courts have allowed the deferral of prepaid income in limited circumstances. In Artnell Co. v. Commissioner, the court held that amounts received on advance ticket sales relating to major league baseball games to be played on fixed dates in the next year could be deferred to that year. In Tampa Bay Devil Rays, Ltd. v. Commissioner, the Tax Court held that deposits received by a new baseball franchise in 1995 and 1996 on advance season tickets for major league baseball games to be played in its first season in 1998 could be deferred until 1998, even though the deferral period was greater than a year. The Tax Court emphasized that the games were to be played on a fixed and definite schedule in 1998 and that deferral more clearly matched the deposits with the related expenses that were incurred and deducted in 1998. T.D. 9330
Congress, the IRS, and Treasury Department have allowed deferral of prepaid income in certain circumstances. For example, section 455 allows taxpayers that have prepaid subscription income for newspapers, magazines, and other periodicals to elect to defer such income to the taxable years during which the liability to furnish or deliver the newspaper, magazine, or periodical exists. Section 1.451-5(b)(1)(ii) allows advance payments for the sale of goods to be deferred to the year the payments are included in gross receipts under the taxpayer’s method of accounting for tax purposes (such as when the goods are shipped or delivered), unless the income is recorded earlier for purposes of the taxpayer’s financial statements. T.D. 9330
Conclusion
In summary, advance payments are generally taxable in the year received, while deposits that must be returned are not. However, eligible taxpayers using an accrual method of accounting may elect to defer a portion of certain advance payments to the following tax year under specific conditions. The determination of whether a payment is an advance payment or a deposit depends on the facts and circumstances, particularly whether the recipient has complete dominion and control over the funds.
If you’re receiving advance payments or deposits, it’s important to properly characterize them and understand the tax implications. For complex situations, consulting with a tax professional is recommended to ensure proper tax treatment.
Try Your AI Tax Assistant for Free!
Ready to transform your practice with agentic AI in tax? See firsthand how our cutting-edge AI tax tools can revolutionize your approach to tax research and planning.